Which jedi confronted palpatine

Luke Skywalker was saved by his father, Darth Vader, who sacrificed his life by destroying the Emperor. The Emperor proceeded to torture Luke for his defiance, which, in turn, led Vader to intercede for Luke.

The ensuing struggle between master and apprentice ended with Sidious' destruction, but Vader was critically damaged in the process. Having sacrificed his life for his son, Vader made peace with Luke before passing into the Force as Anakin Skywalker. In the years following Anakin Skywalker's redemption and death, Luke embarked on a search for Jedi knowledge and learned about Windu's life, including his failed attempt to arrest Palpatine. Holding Windu in high esteem, Skywalker concluded that had it not been for his father's intervention, Windu would have likely succeeded in defeating Palpatine.

Ian McDiarmid , the actor who portrayed Palpatine, didn't enjoy filming these scenes. As a Shakespearean actor, filming high-speed sword fighting did not appeal to him. He had only about five days to learn the choreography his stunt double would not perform from the stunt coordinator, Nick Gillard. As an older man, he wasn't as dexterous as his opponents and, occasionally, he would be hit over the day's filming.

McDiarmid did, however, have some respect for Samuel L. Jackson 's abilities. The film's producer, Rick McCallum , was worried about how the scene would turn out because of this, but was very happy with the final result.

On the other hand, Windu's actor, Samuel L. Jackson, had been waiting for this scene since he was hired. One of the requests he made during negotiations for the part was for his character to die spectacularly at the end and not die "like some punk. During shooting, Jackson and the crew joked about having Windu surviving the duel and returning for a post-credit scene. The duel went through several changes during production. One of the earlier versions of the scene had Anakin Skywalker present in Palpatine's office from the beginning, witnessing the fight between Palpatine and the Jedi until entering to succor Palpatine from Windu's will.

However, the shoot was difficult as the gloves worn by the Jedi Knights made it difficult to grab the lightsaber hilts, leading to the scene's reshoot on August 27 , Rather than being thrown out the window, Windu just fell the ground dead after receiving Palpatine's lightning in this version. According to the screenplay of Episode III, the Chancellor's Rodian aide Dar Wac and two members of the Senate Guard originally had a cameo appearance before the Jedi entered Palpatine's office, in which they would have tried to stop the Jedi only to be Force pushed into the walls by them.

The screenplay also indicates Windu attempted to defend himself with his remaining hand after he was betrayed by Skywalker. Wookieepedia Explore. Star Wars. Clone Wars Droids Ewoks. Administrators' noticeboard IRC Discord. Tutorials Editing sandbox Things to do Status article nominations Featured article nominations Good article nominations Comprehensive article nominations.

Explore Wikis Community Central. Register Don't have an account? Duel in Palpatine's office. Edit source History Talk 0. Do you like this video? Play Sound. The title of this article is conjectural. I think Chancellor Palpatine is a Sith Lord. He's been trained to use the Dark Side. We must move quickly if the Jedi Order is to survive.

Mace Windu : " I am going to end this, once and for all! He must stand trial. Welcome to Star Wars Week! To celebrate the year anniversary of Revenge of the Sith May 19 and the year anniversary of The Empire Strikes Back May 21 , we're talking about our favorite sci-fi franchise for nine days straight. Obi-Wan is one of the small handful of characters to see Sheev Palpatine across two trilogies. Don't forget the entire "lost planet" plotline in Attack of the Clones where Kenobi uncovers the whole Clone Wars plot.

In the prequels, Obi-Wan is the biggest threat to Palpatine emotionally. As Anakin's Jedi Master, he's got direct responsibility to raise him and train him as the Chosen One.

Unfortunately, we know how that turns out. Palpatine cunningly uses Obi-Wan as a tool, driving a wedge between him and the future Darth Vader. The biggest selling point in Rey's case against Palpatine is obvious: she's the one who beat him in The Rise of Skywalker. For now, anyway. All the Jedi are within her, so naturally, that would make her as intimidating as all the Jedi who came before her combined, right? Then again, Rey does have Palpatine blood, and her Dark Rey side is a fundamental part of who she is.

Perhaps that family connection takes the edge off the dynasty of Jedi that came before her. Without her intense Force bond with Kylo Ren, the situation may have turned out far differently. Instead, he sees them as pawns on his chessboard. This seems like the ideal choice for this quintessential Star Wars villain, but where does it leave the pathos behind Sheev the person?

Beyond the cloning and genocide, Palpatine is a human being with emotions, right? In the wise words of one Yoda: Fear is the path to the Dark Side. How could Palpatine lead the Dark side without knowing that fear? The Chancellor began begging for mercy, and claimed he was too weak to continue fighting. After Sidious ceased his attack, Windu announced that he had no choice but to eliminate the Dark Lord once and for all.

For, having just experienced first hand the true, terrifying depth of Sidious's power, Windu now saw him as too great a threat to the Republic to be kept alive. Skywalker pleaded with him to spare Sidious, stating that the best course of action was for Sidious to stand trial, but Windu refused, believing that Sidious's influence would sway the Court's decision in the Sith Lord's favor. Ironically, when explaining this, Mace used the exact same argument for killing Sidious that Sidious himself gave to Anakin for why Dooku needed to be killed earlier —that Sidious was far too great of a threat to be kept alive.

Skywalker further pressed that killing Sidious in cold blood was not the Jedi way. But Windu raised his blade to deliver the killing blow, and Skywalker, reacting in a moment of despair, cut off the unsuspecting Windu's sword hand. Seeing this, Sidious immediately ceased feigning weakness and unleashed a withering barrage of Force lightning at the helpless Jedi Master, also gloating about his unlimited power. After torturing him for a few moments, Sidious used the Force to push Windu out of the broken window, whereupon he met his death on impact with the streets below.

Skywalker had not realized that Sidious was going to kill Windu [7] and fell to his knees in shock at his unwitting participation in the Jedi Master's murder. Sidious congratulated him, telling Skywalker that he was fulfilling his destiny and that he would help him find the secrets to saving Amidala's life. The Dark Lord then admitted in a round-about way that cheating death was a power only his Master had achieved, revealing he did not actually know the secret to stopping death.

Furthermore, though Sidious had admitted to not knowing how to cheat death, he believed that joining the Dark Lord was still his best chance to save Amidala. He resigned himself to his fate and knelt before Sidious, swearing an oath to be his Sith apprentice. While he hoped that he and Sidious could discover the secret of immortality together, Skywalker no longer saw his new master as a friend worth defending. Now, the man was merely a necessary evil worth tolerating until the time was right to take his place.

Though horrified at what he had done, and what he was becoming, Skywalker knew there was no turning back from his dark path, so he pledged to Sidious that he would do whatever Sidious asked in return for his assistance in saving Amidala. Sidious named his new apprentice Darth Vader and tasked him with the sterilization of the Jedi Temple.

Furthermore, to every clone trooper in the Grand Army of the Republic , Sidious issued Order 66 ; the clones were ordered to eliminate their Jedi Commanders and Generals , and marked all Jedi as enemies of the Republic.

The Great Jedi Purge had begun. Vader stormed the Temple, leading the st Legion , [10] and proceeded to kill nearly every Jedi within its walls.

The Temple was set ablaze and reduced to ruins while all of Galactic City watched. Shortly thereafter, Sidious traveled to the Senate Rotunda and presented the audio recording of Windu's assault on his life as evidence of what he called the "Jedi Rebellion" [1] or the "Jedi Revolt," [11] an attempt by the Order to overthrow the Republic. The activation of the Jedi Masters' lightsabers was digitally confirmed by Republic agents in the audio recording while the activation of Palpatine's lightsaber was neither recorded nor analyzed.

After making his case to the Senate that they needed to take action, Sidious delivered a speech that declared that the Republic was no more, and in its place was a new Galactic Empire. Sidious would later discover Yoda's survival when the latter arrived at his office in the senate, resulting in a climactic duel between the Sith Master and the Jedi Grandmaster, concurrently to similar duel between Obi-Wan Kenobi and the newly-christened Darth Vader.

With Windu's death, some, such as the Jedi Jaina Solo , believed the shatterpoint Force technique was lost. This was untrue, however. Its reputation as a lost art spawned from the rarity of individuals able to perform it, but some like her brother, Jacen Solo , and uncle, Luke Skywalker , learned it by [12] 41 ABY.

The earlier version of the scene had Skywalker present from the start. In the Revenge of the Sith novel , Palpatine spun the duel to prove Jedi were rebelling against the Republic, which was further expanded upon in the reference book The Complete Star Wars Encyclopedia , in which Palpatine called this duel the "Jedi Rebellion. As a Shakespearean actor, filming high-speed sword fighting did not appeal to him. He had only about five days to learn the choreography [14] his stunt double would not perform [7] from the stunt coordinator, Nick Gillard.

As an older man, he was not as dexterous as his opponents and, occasionally, he would be hit over the day's filming. McDiarmid did, however, have some respect towards Samuel L.

Jackson's abilities. Jackson , had been waiting for this scene since he was hired. One of the requests he made during negotiations for the part was for his character to die spectacularly at the end.

In the novelization of Episode III , Obi-Wan Kenobi , Mace Windu, and Shaak Ti all claimed that the arrest team consisted of "four of the greatest swordsmen the Jedi Order has ever produced"—a fact less obvious in the movie since Kolar, Tiin, and Fisto all died within a few seconds of the duel's start. Kenobi further proposed that if Palpatine could eliminate the four Jedi Masters all by himself, then even Yoda and Kenobi together would not be enough to defeat the Dark Lord.

The same book implies that Samuel L. Jackson sincerely believed that Windu, his character, had overpowered Palpatine, even during the lightning struggle. This was either dropped or never filmed. Furthermore, the screenplay stated it was Windu who was being forced onto the ledge after the window was broken, which contradicts the novelization. George Lucas watching the earlier version of the scene. In the novel, a debate between Palpatine and Windu before the duel reflected that even though the audience knew that Palpatine, as a Sith Lord, was behind everything and was ultimately responsible for the war, the Jedi never had any hard evidence of Palpatine's crime to legitimize their arrest attempt.

Even the knowledge of Palpatine's true identity depended solely on the words of an emotionally unstable Anakin Skywalker. Windu also failed to explain why the "philosophical difference" between the Jedi and the Sith would lead to the arrest of Palpatine, which played to the Sith Lord's plan in the secret audio recording, thus undermining the support of the Jedi in the Senate.

As they were extrapolated by different people, there are several differences between the various portrayals of this duel. The version portrayed in the movie is the sole completely canon sequence.

Throughout the battle, the lightsaber hilt Palpatine uses alternates between his own and Skywalker's due to the fact that he was originally going to use Anakin Skywalker's lightsaber against the Jedi.

Skywalker was scripted to be present throughout the duel at first, but the battle was re-choreographed at the last minute and Skywalker was instead scripted to arrive at the exact moment Palpatine lost his weapon.